RENTAL PROPERTY DISPUTES: THE ROLE AND POWERS OF THE RENTAL HOUSING TRIBUNAL
The Rental Housing Act (No. 50 of 1999), in addition to establishing important rights and duties of landlords and tenants when it comes to the lease of immovable property for housing, also sets up a Rental Housing Tribunal (RHT) in each province.
The RHT provides an alternative mechanism for resolving disputes involving residential rental properties. It aims to balance the rights of tenants and landlords and to create mechanisms to protect both tenants and landlords against unfair practices and exploitation, to resolve landlord-tenant disputes quickly, and at minimum cost to the parties.
For tenants and property investors alike, understanding its powers, procedures and the legal effect of its rulings is an important aspect of managing rental property.
Rental Housing Tribunal complaints and mediation
The RHT receives complaints from tenants or landlords, or from interest groups in the sector. It determines if it appears that an unfair practice has occurred, and may then refer the parties to mediation.
If the dispute cannot be resolved at mediation, the Tribunal conducts a hearing to investigate further, sometimes requiring reports to be submitted from the Rental Housing Information Office. It has the power to summon the parties or any other relevant person to give evidence before the Tribunal.
What is an ‘unfair practice’?
The Act defines an unfair practice as an act or omission by a landlord or tenant that contravenes the Act, or a practice prescribed by regulation as unreasonably prejudicing the rights or interests of either party.
The Regulations (which may differ from province to province), in turn, prohibit landlords and tenants from engaging in “oppressive or unreasonable conduct” and prohibit a landlord from undertaking activities that unreasonably interfere with or limit a tenant’s rights, or that are prohibited by the lease, the Regulations, the Rental Housing Act or another law.
They also set out the legal effect of the lease agreement where it is not reduced to writing, or not signed by one or both of the parties, generally seeking to preserve the contract. They require the parties to act in good faith when performing or enforcing their obligations.
It also clarifies that the tenant must pay rent due under the lease, without demand or notice at the time and place agreed upon. Unless a tenant is otherwise notified in writing, rent is payable at the dwelling on the first day of each month.
The lack of maintenance is expressly recognised in the Act as an unfair practice that the Tribunal may order to be discontinued.
Powers to make orders
Following the hearing of the matter, the Tribunal is empowered to make a binding ruling, which it determines is just and fair in the circumstances. It may order compliance with the Rental Housing Act and if it determines that the Act has been breached, may refer the matter for investigation by the relevant authority.
They may make an order for one party to pay another’s reasonable legal costs, they may grant interdicts requiring action or preventing conduct from continuing, and issue orders for the immediate restoration of possession of property to which someone has been unlawfully deprived . They are, however, precluded from dealing with eviction matters, and thus an application for the eviction of illegal occupiers must go through the appropriate Magistrate’s Court or the High Court.
Notable effect of order on landlord and tenant responsibilities
An important effect of making a complaint to the Rental Housing Tribunal is that – for 3 months following the date that it is lodged, or until the Tribunal makes a ruling, whichever comes first – the tenant must continue to pay the rent, the landlord is restricted from evicting the tenant while the tenant pays the rent (being the applicable rental before the complaint, or the amount payable before an escalation), and the landlord must effect the necessary maintenance. It is important to note that this is not a general immunity from eviction proceedings.
The RHT provides tenants and property investors with a specialised mechanism for addressing unfair rental practices without immediately resorting to litigation. By understanding the complaint process and the binding effect of its rulings, both parties can better protect their rights and meet their legal obligations.
It is important to note that you should get appropriate legal advice before approaching the RHT or having to participate in RHT proceedings to ensure that your case has the best possible outcomes.

